Agency Pricing Models Explained

By

Agency Pricing Models Explained

Choosing an agency partner is about more than just portfolio or platform expertise—it’s about alignment. And one of the easiest ways to tell whether you’re aligned? Listen to how they talk about pricing. Because how an agency prices its work and how they communicate that says a lot about how they operate, what they value, and how they handle change, communication, and results.

This blog breaks down common agency pricing models—what they mean, when they work (and don’t), and how Above The Fray approaches pricing differently. Whether you’re exploring a new partnership or just want clarity around how this all works, we’ve got the info you need to understand the mysteries around agency pricing.

Common Agency Pricing Models

Most agencies fall into one of the following pricing models—or use a hybrid of a few.

Hourly (Open-Ended)

This is the most straightforward—and often the most risky for clients. Agencies bill for every hour spent without a cap, usually at variable rates depending on the team member or service type.

  • When it works: For small, reactive projects with limited scope.
  • The downside: It puts all the risk on the client. Costs can balloon without warning, and it can be difficult to predict timelines or budget accurately.

Flat-Fee

You agree to a fixed price for a defined set of deliverables.

  • When it works: For tightly-scoped, well-understood work that’s unlikely to change.
  • The downside: It’s rigid. Clients often hesitate to request additional needs, and agencies often resist any deviation—resulting in strained communication or change orders that feel punitive.

Retainer

You pay a set amount each month for a bucket of hours or ongoing support. Some retainers are use-it-or-lose-it, others may allow carryover.

  • When it works: For long-term partnerships with ongoing needs across content, strategy, development, design, etc.
  • The downside: Some agencies don’t provide clarity on what the retainer is used for, or resist transparency around time tracking.

Value-Based Pricing

Pricing based on outcomes or perceived value rather than time or deliverables.

  • When it works: For performance-driven engagements (like ad campaigns with clear KPIs).
  • The downside: It can be fuzzy and feel arbitrary. There's often a disconnect between the value created and the effort invested—and things can get murky if goals shift mid-project.

How We Do It at Above The Fray

1. We Operate on a Not-to-Exceed, Time & Materials Basis

At ATF, transparency isn’t a buzzword—it’s baked into how we work. As a service organization, transparency around detailed time tracking & reporting is part of our core and our successful outcomes. We track in multiple ways to provide the whole picture for our clients, and provide detailed monthly reports that break these down:

  • Overall budget usage
  • Initiative-based usage
  • Resource-based usage
  • Issue/ticket-based usage

We also operate on a not-to-exceed model—if less time is needed than what we estimated, that unused budget is available for other work.

2. We Use a Rate Card

Instead of relying on a single “blended rate,” we use a tiered rate card to more accurately reflect the global diversity of our team and the depth of expertise involved in our work. This allows us to remain competitive, transparent, and fair.

Our rate card includes:

  • Onshore rates
  • Nearshore rates (LATAM & EU)
  • Offshore rates (APAC & EMEA)
  • Specialist rates (for highly specialized roles or niche expertise)

This model reflects our investment in building a bona fide elite team of certified subject-matter specialists—and helps us pass along the competitive advantages of regional salary variation to our clients. In other words: you get the right expertise at the right rate, without compromise.

3. We Offer Monthly Buckets with Flexibility

For retainers, we operate on a predictable monthly cadence—with a set monthly budget that cannot be exceeded without written approval. If additional budget is approved and used, it’s rolled into the following invoice, but the next month resets with the original not-to-exceed amount unless otherwise discussed.

There’s no long-term lock-in on any of our retainer contracts: if you want to adjust or cancel, we just ask for 30 days’ notice ahead of a new billing cycle.

4. Our Project Work Is Scoped, Sprint-Based, and Backed by Our Estimates

For larger projects like new site builds or custom development, we estimate costs per phase—Discovery, Design, Build—based on a scoped number of sprints and the resourcing required to deliver on time and on budget.

We bill for actual hours worked and we stand by our estimates.That means, if the agreed-upon scope doesn’t change and the work ends up taking more time than projected, we absorb the overage. That’s part of our commitment to fair pricing and mutual trust—clients shouldn’t be penalized for our miscalculation.

Of course, if your needs evolve or scope expands mid-project, we’ll talk through it and handle the change via a clear, collaborative change order process—no surprises.

Our goal isn’t just to deliver what was promised—it’s to do so with transparency, accountability, and partnership at the core.

Why It Matters

We’ve designed this approach to reduce anxiety, eliminate surprises, and build trust. We know that especially in the early stages of working together—there can be uncertainty. That’s why our entire service delivery is built around:

  • Judicious and fair use of budget
  • Precision in communications
  • Transparency in reporting
  • White-glove responses to concerns
  • Empathy in understanding our client’s challenges

Our North Star is long-term efficiency, growth, and our clients’ best interests—not billing as much as we can. We want our clients to feel confident in our partnership and proud of the work we do together.

Interested in learning more about what we do? Check out our service offerings or contact us to schedule an alignment call to see if your needs match up with the things we do best.